Posted this in a more recent thread, but wanted to copy and past it here for those who might find it in the future.
So, I think after 3 years of guessing, I might finally have an answer. I spoke with the great guys over at Best Motor Werks in Columbus about my car. They pulled the fuel filter and said it was extremely dirty! They wont be able to test drive it till after the weekend, but they are confident that is what is causing the issues. I will report back and let you everyone know.
Read more: http://www.motoringalliance.com/forums/mid-ohio-motoring/13583-r53-issues-after-river-run-4.html#ixzz2uBbCXPFS
Page 1 of 2
-
agranger MINI of the Month June 2009Supporting Member
-
oh and a dirty fuel filter can cause it as well because if the engine starts to get fuel starved it will adjust the timing and ign to compensate...also you might want to look at your fuel pump...depending on its age it might not be working as well too...i know i replaced my pump at about 180k and the plastic was so dry the spring loaded top popped out like a jack in the box as soon as Colin pulled the access cover
-
Like x 2
- List
-
-
BThayer23 Well-Known Member
-
the DT BPV isnt a radical redesign its just a stock one with a stiffer spring...i had one in my R53 for 140k miles with never an issue...i pulled the throttle body off every once in awhile and cleaned the butterfly valve because after years of use it will gunk on it...also pull the intercooler off and check the boots and the other vac lines...sometimes a small crack or tear in a boot or hose can cause a yoyo effect
-
Like x 1
- List
-
-
Check your IC boots, mine did something similar. My boots were worn out and not sealing, funny thing was it seemed only to act up during lower RPM/boost. Just a suggestion, good luck.
-
Crashton Club Coordinator
Maybe the new shift knob is too heavy or something. Or could it be you went to some club. We at the un-club were glad to see you this morning.
When you narrow this down let us know what it was. I have no clue on this one. miniconcarne may be onto something. -
I'm not sure either Sean, but I'd recommend calling Chad at DT and see what he has to say before you bring it to any local shop. If it's just replacing the intercooler boots or something simple, you can probably do it yourself.
My guess though: it has something to do with a sticking bypass valve. -
Wouldn't he have a code if he were losing boost that drastically? My DSC has been acting up lately similar to how the OP's is. Does the light for your DSC blink when your car is doing this? Another thing you can try is turn off the DSC and see if the problem is still there. you may have a overly sensitive speed sensor or one that is failing but not quite ready to get you the xmas tree lights.
-
agranger MINI of the Month June 2009Supporting Member
When my IC boots were leaking just slightly I got a code and a SES light.
-
BThayer23 Well-Known Member
-
agranger MINI of the Month June 2009Supporting Member
http://www.motoringalliance.com/library/1st-generation-mini-cooper-how-to-3/replacing-the-crank-pulley-101/#axzz1pcka6KqM
Given your loose IC boot, that's probably your problem.
Good luck!
Page 1 of 2