Most liked posts in thread: Life Choices

3D printers are evolving, some new models with great enhancements in 2020. My D-I-L is a designer, they just started a new company this month. So watch for new stuff ourt of Loveland.

Go with the MIG and wait 6 to 12 months for the best in 3D.

 

Not only that, but there are companies now that will print your stuff for you, so you don't have to learn CAD in order to print something.
I use my MIG all the time, you just never know when you will need it for a project, big or small.
Most of the plastic bits you need for a MINI/Mini are still available too....don't know about the Samurai....

 

You'll also learn how to grind welds then!

My first project the welds were awful, I think I ground off more than I left but I learned - as you said. Best way to learn is to stick yourself in and go, but if you have someone who knows how at your elbow, you'll learn quicker and your welds will actually be strong. Post picks of your project so we can see what you're going to do!

One thing I really recommend - buy a Mig with gas, don't use flux core - you're welds will be better and cleaner. Oh, and cheap Harbor Freight welders may work OK, but a name brand will have a much higher duty cycle (cheap welders are usually only 20%, good ones are closer to 90% ) and give cleaner, better welds with good penetration. You can buy a Lincoln for not a whole lot more than a cheap HF....and get a good auto darkening helmet too.

 

If these are the only choices most definitely the welder

 

MIG

3D printer prices will keep falling in price.

 

Welder, I didn't see Nik Blackhurst use a 3d printer.

 

Sometimes it's cheaper, better and the result comes quicker if you just hire the guy that knows how to build one, plus you'll need a big ass tubing bender and a notcher to build that...... can't wait to see the results. Good luck with the project!

 

You don't need all that, chisels and hammers not needed with Mig if you use gas, the welds will be clean, the most you'll need is a wire brush.

f course, it never hurts to suit up properly......

 

My first choice would also be the welder.