1st Gen R53 Cooper S Poor RMW Tune Experience

Welcome to M/A...

That is an interesting 3rd post. I'll sit back & see what develops. opcorn:

 

Welcome to M/A...... What he said ..... ^^^^

 

Interesting third post indeed!!!! Kinda makes you wonder what the true intent is....just sayin'

 

Well...lets see what pans out hereopcorn:

 

Welcome to M/A....
Not related to the RMW tune experience, but maybe related to your pinging issue.....

Read the part about 2.0 Fuel System Cleaner Plus: "Combustion Chamber".... Just wondering if you have a carbon buildup issue inside the cylinders. The octane additive and changes to the tune might be masking the problem???? If it is carbon buildup related, a tune may not remove the carbon and may not fix the ping.....

Just considering another angle to your problem....

http://www.bmw-planet.com/lib/Operating%20Fluids%20-%20Fuel%20System.pdf

 

My father told me the nice folks at the Buick service department told him that pinging was the sound of gas mileage. So there you have it, gas mileage my friends goes ping...

Edit..... Techron is my friend.

 

I'm sure that there is another side to this story at the very least....

 

I like how my 2nd post was removed.....?

 

Posts that do nothing to move the conversation in a forward manner and only serve to be fanboy like have been unapproved until normal access is available and the can judged on their merit.

So yeah, untill I get back to a pc they are unapproved.

We can discuss in person later in the week if desired.

 

Ok cool, see you at Fontana Nathan.

I too look forward to discussing the "we / them" issue also.

Back on topic, I love my RMW tune and have no problem working with or getting in contact with Jan. I find the OP's post very odd.

 

:beer interesting..

Just saying......................

Thumper

 

Let's keep in mind that every vendor selling any product, not only in the MINI realm, is going to have an issue with a customer at some point in time. No one or group is perfect. It is how a vendor handles that issue is what makes or breaks them in the long run.

There is no need for fans and detractors of a vendor to pile in with platitudes, attacks of the OP nor hits against the vendor.

We all need to sit back and see how this plays out please. Also, Internet time is short, but real time is not. With this being a week where the players in this little drama may be traveling and be without reliable means of communication outside of our little Dragon world we all need to be patient.

 

Well said!

 

I did offer help...replace aftermarket coil and plug wires. See my post on the NAM.

But the facts are when you Hp tune a car little things show up that you did not notice before.

Just like adding any polly bushings to you motor, you are going to get MVH and hear things rattle that never made a sound before.

If you have nothing to offer to help the guy out stay on the sidelines.

 

Advice added.....

Yet again another car that is modded until it is not what the owner wants. This seems to be a trend. I know lots of guys want to get all they can from their car, but with that can come problems one has to work through. You either accept that or don't go that far in your quest for performance.

My advice to the OP is return to a less aggressive setup & enjoy your MINI.

I truly hope I made your day a little better by helping & somehow improved this thread before it crashes & burns.

opcorn:

 

What part of...

There is no need for fans and detractors of a vendor to pile in with platitudes, attacks of the OP nor hits against the vendor.

...was not understood.

Its a beautiful day at Fontana, I have better things to than watch this thread all day.

 

Nate.. have you ever visited the camp ground at NIGHT?? Big bon fires and beer drinking!! Well worth the short hop out of Fontana.. LOL unless it is 'Ways Margareta Nite"

Just saying.............................

Thumper

 

With regards to any, "tooner", your tuner better have a good solid mechanical background, as tuning a car will not remove mechanical problems, but only intensify problems even more! Not sure if the OP's problems are mechanical related, or we're intensified by a tune? But it's also the tuners responsibility to warn potential customers that mechanical problems should be completely removed before tuning. Hope the OP gets his car sorted, as the whole point is to go out and have fun driving his car

 

I would like to add if you are having your car tuned remotely buy any tuner it is the car owners responsibility to make sure the car is mechanically sound before you get your car tuned. If you are not qualified to do so Pay someone that is.

Just like it is your responsibility to maintain your car so it passes State Inspection and Emissions. ( if your State requires either or both, PA requires both Yearly) If your car fails either test it is you that has to have the car fixed. Also the State test are Pass or Fail you still pay.

I have read many posts on multiple fourms and heard many times from Jan's own mouth the list of things that need to be checked or sorted before anyone gets any car tuned. For example but not limited to, he recommends the obvious such as a new belt or belts depending on car, fresh plugs if you still have your day one plugs that came with your car the day you picked it up, a clean air filter, fresh oil change if you are close to having it changed, and the list goes on. Also the fuel you run everyday. Don't run 89 daily and pull up on tune day with full tank of 93 and 3 bottles of octain boost in your tank just to get a high number and then go back to 89. That will not work with your 93 tune.

I personally and others have add many more things like checking fuel pressure and compression test just because I am very OCD about my car and I want everything in tip top shape all the time. That's also why I change my oil every 3k, oil is cheap, rebuilds are not.

All these things are the car owners responsibility NOT the tuners, especially when being remotely tuned.

You don't need to be an ASE certified mechanic to tune cars but you did need to know how the modern day car not old Hot Rods work with ECUs. Common sense and daily maintainance will make most modern day cars last a long time and when you modify your car and commit big bucks you have to maintain it and expect higher maintenance levels. This is a self chosen path and and each person must commit to themselves. If anyone cannot do this they should never mod a car from the beginning.

P.S. the word "tooner" was a joke that you did not get.