Most liked posts in thread: Some MINI Models May Be on Chopping Block

What about the F55? Four doors and a hatch, just a bit longer than the Hardtop but about the same height.

My guess is that this will take the place of the place of the Clubman.

 

Maybe this is MINIs shooting-brake...hmmmm

 

That I think is MINI's next abomination. The 5 door stretch limo Cooper. :frown2:

 

I was just reading this months Automobile magazine that the next Clubbie would have 4 doors and be about a foot longer. Then again, that could have been in a previous interview.

 

Yeah... too many internal competitors in the 'large MINI' segment. Bye bye Clubman (no matter how much fun you are to drive).

I hadn't thought about the 4-seat vs Coupe/roadster 'vert question before. Do you really need 2 drop-tops in the line-up?

 

And it would be called the Countryman?

 

The last time I had a car with four doors all of my kids were still on my payroll. That was the predecessor to my MINI, a Subaru Outback wagon (which actually had more cargo space than a lot of SUVs, and wouldn't flip over when fully utilized).

My Clubbie is perfect for me. Small and nimble enough to get around the Brontosaurus and Stegosaurus SUVs on the road, but big enough to handle a Costco run.

 

I tend to agree with you. I actually like the idea of a JCW Countryman, but the price point seems too high for what you are getting.

 

Yup... that's the unfortunate part. MINI is making the cars WAY too expensive.

The other unfortunate part is that people will still buy them for that price so then MINI has no reason to re-evaluate the cost.

 

The Clubman was the reason I bought a MINI. Go kart that'll hold two kids in the back, and the wife thinks its completely impractical. The Clubman body style has history with MINI. Dump the Coupe and Roadster, I don't feel that they really fit in the lineup anyway. Or the Countryman. Or the Paceman.

 

Yeah they are expensive. But the alternatives are the CRV, RAV4 etc. and they aren't as good.

 

Nissan Juke I think is more of an alternative to the CM, they are about the same size. Juke MSRP is $20,280 - $26,940.


I find this whole statement by Jim McDowell interesting as MINI has stated in the past how they will have many more models see the following article: MINI & BMW to Dramatically Expand Small Car Offerings | BimmerFile

"Surprisingly, this even includes a MINI four door sedan. According to those who’ve seen the proposal, it’s an extremely attractive car that leverages the MINI floating roof and wrap-around glass. Apparently, the rear is similar to the Paceman, with sculpted front lines reminiscent of the 2008 MINI Crossover Concept." The looks like the picture I just posted.

 

The fact that nobody cares enough about the vert to even comment on it, while there have been umpteem additional posts about the certainly-marginalized-and-likely-to-be-killed Clubman, proves my point. The four seat Mini convertible is a goner.

:cryin:

 

I'm not too sure about that, mainly because it is based on the Hardtop. I feel like MINI will keep at least one convertible style.

 

I'd guess the sales numbers would dictate which one gets the ax. Is the roadster outselling the vert? If I was a betting man I'd bet a donut or two on the vert going away. Probably to me replaced by the JCW Countryguy vert. :wink:

Take car of your vert Paul. They are endangered.

 

Hey... I mentioned it!

And if anything, I think that they would keep the 4-seater and move the 2-seat production to allow more of the 2-seat hard-tops. Kinda depends on the numbers.

 

Yeah, but the R52/R57 has always been a car of many compromises, and it's a pretty serious modification / bastardization of the hardtop. The Roadster is MUCH more closely aligned to the Coupe IMO, and makes much more sense in the model lineup.

Don't get me wrong - for those of us who 1) MUST have a MINI, 2) MUST have a convertible, and 3) MUST have 4 seats, the convertible is must-have (obviously)... but there just plain ain't a lot of us, and the sales numbers back that up: 4813 'verts sold in the US in 2012, out of 102,250 total MINIs - less than 5% of total sales. 2371 roadsters sold in a partial year with limited visibility and availability, compared to the verts. YTD through March 2013, 719 verts vs. 982 a year ago (down 26.8%), 655 Roadsters sold so far this year. I expect Roadsters to outsell verts this year. With some of the "cute" car buyers who were originally drawn to Mini now having 4 seat convertible options from VW and Fiat, Game over.

Makes me sad, but it is what it is. I really, really wanted a next gen MINI convertible with an awesome new engine and transmission. Oh, well.

 

Here is my opinion, the Coupe/Roadster are just as out of sync with Mini heritage as the Countryman/Paceman. At least the Clubman is similar to the Austin Mini Van/Traveller. With that said, I say axe the Roadster (which is my least favorite variant) and kill the Paceman. I am curious to see what a sedan version would look like, would it be a modern 4 door version of a Riley Elf?

All I know is that there seems to be more owners that consider their MINI as just a car then there are those of us that post in all the various MINI forums. I'm fine with that as long as MINI continues to make variants that are still fun to drive for the rest of us.

 

Part of why they are making so many models is the connection with BMW, I think. X1, X3, X5, X6, now the smaller version of the X6...the X4, they will have series of every number, GT models, etc. etc. And that mindset has definitely seeped into MINI HQ.

They are over-engineering things again....

 

Er?!? The Clubvan/man was an original mini.

So how can you say to get rid of it now and "keep MINI mini"?!?

And BTW, they will keep the new bigger vehicles. The market surveys they did prior told them folks in the USA wanted make-believe SUVs, and now the results confirm it. All of the hoopla around the "MINI community" don't mean squat back at corporate compared to the hoopla that is raised around the sales/profits/$$$ from selling bigger vehicles in the US.

As I stated earlier, the Clubman meets *my* needs, just as all of my previous non-MINI vehicles did. If by the time my current MINI goes the way of all flesh and MINI doesn't offer a vehicle that meets *my* needs, sadly or not, then I will move on.

But your wish that they produce nothing but the smallest of MINIS...maybe you should consider a FIAT.