Welcome, thanks for joining Motoring Alliance.
-
-
Mr. Jim MudsharkLifetime Supporter
Welcome to M/A!
-
Redbeard JCW: because fast is fun!Supporting Member
In 2008 and 2009 there were a few noteable issues with the engines. Most of it can be taken care of via warranty/recall at no cost to you. You perform a search on this forum for more details but there have been issues with (click the text for links): High Pressure Fuel Pumps, Timing Chain Tensioners, Carbon build-up on intake valves, and there was a recall just issued for the secondary water-pump.
I might recommend you look at a 2010+ model as the high pressure fuel pump and timing chain tensioner issues were resolved. Also, the likelyhood of more carbon build-up is reduced on a newer model with fewer miles.
It's a bit daunting. Some folks will recommend, for reliability, go with a naturally aspirated (non-turbo or Justa) Mini. I'd have to agree on that front. As far as the fun to drive factor I'd totally recommend getting an S (turbo model).
I'd be a liar if I said my R56 was all peaches and cream. I'd be an even bigger liar if I said that this car was anything but the most fun vehicle I've ever owned. Good luck selling your G35x and I hope to see you in a Clubman soon. -
Thanks for the warm welcome!
Redbeard, thanks for that information. I have to admit, I tend to like to have a little more pep in my cars. The great thing as far as warranty issues, I have the Mini dealer in walking distance.When I get mine, I will surely take it in to see if any of those issues have been addressed. If not, in she goes.
I see you take yours to the track. Do you see many clubmans there? I was curious if the clubman is any good for something like that. I would love to one day take mine to the track. That may just require a second mini. :biggrin5: -
Redbeard JCW: because fast is fun!Supporting Member
When I ordered mine there was a possibility that they had gotten the order wrong (it obviously turned out okay just some confusion with labeling). I they had there was a '09 JCW Clubman at the dealer that I would have considered.
Tracking a a Clubman is completely feasable. In fact, if you are just doing track days I'd argue they are better as it's easier to get your track-day gear in the car. The MINI's are a blast on the track. Tossable and forgiving. You don't need a second car but I recommend upgrading your brake fluid and pads as well as a spare set of wheels and good tires just for the track. -
I mentioned the idea of taking the Mini to the track.......she said noooo. She will eventually cave. I told her it isn't any more dangerous than taking my Jeep four wheeling. Probably a better chance of rolling the jeep than the mini. As far as hauling the gear goes, If I have a lot of gear to take, I can always throw it on the trailer. I trailer the Jeep when I take it up in the mountains. -
Redbeard JCW: because fast is fun!Supporting Member
Good luck selling the G35. Hope to see a "Look what I bought" post soon. -
Well, now we are thinking about getting a Cooper s instead of a Clubman s. We don't want to spend as much money, and figured we could get something a little older. That being said, my budget is dropping to around $12-13K. I am guessing that will put me in the year range of 03-06. If I understand correctly, that is a 1st gen. What are the big things to look for, and major differences from 1st gen to 2nd gen? Other than being newer, is there a real benefit of having a 2nd gen?
-
Mr. Jim MudsharkLifetime Supporter
Go for 05-06 S these were the best years for the gen 1's.
-
Redbeard JCW: because fast is fun!Supporting Member
Fairly large differences. Gen 1 is supercharged versus turbocharged in the S models. I have heard the CVT transmissions are problematic. General advice to to look for a manual.
-
I've heard to watch the expansion tank for the supercharger as they tend to leak -
Thanks for all the info.
I like the manual trans thought. I was leaning towards the manual anyway. My wife will need to learn to drive manual, but I have already started teaching her.
I have never owned a supercharged vehicle, so I guess I will do some research on them, just for my knowledge.