Cross the Yoko A008 off your list, it's a 25 year old design at this point and tire technology has gotten much better.
I've used the Hankook RS2 before as a track tire and it lasted quite long, so long in fact the compound was dead before the tread was gone.
The AD08 is a brand new tire, just coming on the market. Saw my first one at MOTD in fact in the Yoko booth there. Some early production models were available to Time Attack drivers but I don't much about them. At almost $200 ea thats a lot for an unproven tire on a MINI, seems as the Scooby folks like then though. Of course the Yoko rep was very happy with the massive 295's on the back of his Z Car, and he does track them at Road Atlanta often.
S-Drive, run away, don't even think about them, good rain tires, not for the track at all.
The rest I have no experience with.
Page 1 of 2
-
-
I don't know where you're getting those tire prices, and maybe the idea is simply to get relative prices, but Edge Racing has the Falken RT-615s for $92ish, significantly less than the $132 you quote. I've bought from them, so they are legit.
I have had good luck with the RT-615s, but not so with the Yokohama Spec2s I run now. They are just too loud and handle unpredictably. I can't and prolly won't wait for them to wear out. -
Umm...Edge Racing went out of business.
-
-
old81 Club CoordinatorLifetime Supporter
- May 4, 2009
- 1,542
- Used to work making computers run fast!
- Ratings:
- +1,731 / 5 / -0
Thanks for the comments. My Boulder dealer is a Tirerack +++ installer, too.
When you compare his pricing with TR and shipping, it's pretty close, not at the bottom of the scale but good.
I'm still searching. I am thinking I will go for a UHP or Max Perf. and not an EP.
Road comfort versus sticky on the track two or three times each summer.
I do have my 16s with GY DS-G3s for lapping days.
Again, comments? And Thanks for the inputs. :smile5: -
old81 Club CoordinatorLifetime Supporter
- May 4, 2009
- 1,542
- Used to work making computers run fast!
- Ratings:
- +1,731 / 5 / -0
Again Thanks, DrP, I really like the folks at EdgeRacing. Where did some of those folks go?
Anyone know? -
BlimeyCabrio Oscar Goldman of MINIsLifetime Supporter
- May 4, 2009
- 2,896
- Professional Facilitator and Alignment Consultant
- Ratings:
- +2,896 / 0 / -0
FWIW.... I'm really liking my NeoGens.... I'm confident some of the other tires will be a little stiffer and a little stickier... but for the price..... the NeoGens are fantastic and seem to be wearing well. If you were looking for one set to use for street and track days, I'd suggest something else... but as a primary street tire for a guy who likes to drive hard... the NG's are a steal... and save a ton of money for other mods....
-
old81 Club CoordinatorLifetime Supporter
- May 4, 2009
- 1,542
- Used to work making computers run fast!
- Ratings:
- +1,731 / 5 / -0
Thanks Paul, I'm leaning toward the Exaltos or the NeoGens, but want the XSs but then I would need another set of light wheels to really make the XSs great on track.
Just not going to happen soon, to much going out just to comfortable on track, XP10/XP8 pads and stuff.
Paul, a quick question, you running 215/45/17 or 16 on your NeoGens?
Thanks,
Don -
I just got a set of the Neo Gen's (215/35/18)
After exhaustive research (you'd think I had better things to do!, but a OC Mini owner knows no bounds) I came across the Nitto's. I found em' on a test by Consumer Reports for Ultra High Perforamance All Seasons. Supposed to be sticky wet/dry and wear evenly with some longevity.
Asked the boys on NAM and got good feedback
Installing next week when set of wheels #2 shows up.
CAN NOT WAIT!
Will post back when I get a couple miles on em'
Been dealing with some -
old81 Club CoordinatorLifetime Supporter
- May 4, 2009
- 1,542
- Used to work making computers run fast!
- Ratings:
- +1,731 / 5 / -0
Thanks Tim, I will probably go the NeoGens on my Challenge Wheels.
Really don't need the XS's or want the them for daily drivers. :cryin: -
old81 Club CoordinatorLifetime Supporter
- May 4, 2009
- 1,542
- Used to work making computers run fast!
- Ratings:
- +1,731 / 5 / -0
NeoGens
Update:
I decided to order Nitto NeoGens in 215/45/17 for the 09 JCW Challenge wheels. :aureola:
Timing and overall need. I will let you know what I think after I get them on the wheels in a couple of weeks.
Our local dealer and warehouse is now waiting for a lot of UHP tires to be shipped as a lot are on back order.
It must be summer and racing season. :lol:
Thanks to all for the commentary and help.
Don -
MINIMaybee Club Coordinator
I think you'll like the Nittos Don. Very sticky IMO, not such a harsh ride and minimal road noise - good DD tires. Plus they look aggressive.
-
Don,
What did you end up getting? Never mind. There is a page 2! -
oldskool New MemberLifetime Supporter
I run the neo's currently as my street tire , they were a bit squirmy at first, but once they had a few miles on them they have proved to be very competent. They are great in foreward bite especially in wet situations very common here in south florida. I would not use them on the track as they would most likely suck. They do wear like steel...The falkens they replaced...615's were very good, but also quite a more expensive product...as you know we were stretching the budget more this time due to an increase in bodywork costs....guardrails just dont yield...
-
I think I'm too late, but...
215/40-17 Hankook RS2s still available at TireRack for $75 each.
Currently Available Prices and Sizes
Great deal. Got these after burning through the Kumho XS in about 15k miles. I think I like the Hankooks better. Sidewall seems stiffer and turn in crisper, with just as much total grip. Prior to the Kumhos I had the Z1s, which were way too stiff for a MINI-weight car as a street tire, imo. Great on the track, though... -
truly appreciate this input.
my pirelli p zeros are worn and have been having fun running some 15inch holies /BFG's
but want to get a 215/45 17 back on my konig feathers.
was considering Yoko S drives , but mounting negative reviews has me leaning to
kumho or nitto.
boxcars -
Follow up to my post install.
6 mo's on and the Neo Gen's still get a huge thumbs up. Think Blimey and I agreed on a great adjective 'predictable'. Great road tires, work great in the rain, you can corner about as hard as the MINI can. Believe me Paul and I tried at MSSD. I have not taken them on the track so I can't speak to that....yet
I got the 215/35/18's and my only regret is not getting the 215/40's or even the 225/40's -
I just put on a set of kumho ecsta ASX 215/45x17 and I love them. I got them from Discount Tire Direct (800-589-6789). Talk to Brad, ext.51859. There was a sale and I only paid $85.00 per. I live in n.w. Pa. and you never know what the weather brings.
My 2 cents :crazy:
Mark -
You really have an apples and oranges list there. Check out Ryan’s Tire Choices: http://www.motoringalliance.com/forums/wheels-tires/741-quickie-guide-tires-mid-2009-a.html#post2685
Page 1 of 2