Page 1 of 3
-
-
Nathan, I had a similar problem as you and Mike.... shortly after I installed them they started rattling like crazy. One weekend I was under the car trying to tighten them back up and got pissed and dropped the sub frame and welded them in place at both the end and the base. Then just for good measure, I reinstalled the set screws and have not had any issue since.
When I first installed them, I was skeptical that 6 tiny set screws were going to hold the sleeve in place.... I wasn't super happy to find out that I was correct.... come to think of it, I have not been super happy with the fit of most of the Alta parts.... -
I wonder if a better way would be to drill and tap the end of the control arm to match the set screw then use a bolt with a bit of red Loctite. Welding is so final.
The clunking I just lived with is gone. The MINI down right sorta semi quiet now, if you tune out the exhaust... -
-
ScottinBend Space CowboySupporting Member
If you tack weld the end, can't you just grind it off?
Mine was welded at the time of install. Our club has some very good mechanics and shops available to us and he won't install one w/o having the ends welded. And none of the many he has installed ever rattled. -
Mine was the first this this tech had ever installed. Need to turn on the wayback machine to take us to that heady time 2.5 years ago when I was still learning how to mod a MINI. Since then, not only have I learned better but the tech said today he's weld more than he's installed. He's installed more then a few too...
-
I'll say it again, you buy Alta, it's your falta
-
Detroit Tuned Well-Known MemberMotoring Alliance Founding Sponsor
i weld each one we install.
-
ScottinBend Space CowboySupporting Member
At least it's not M7..........:lol:
-
I havent lost any set screws yet and i have driven on them for 10 months. I have just now developed the dreaded rattle. Anyway, this may be a dumb question, but i want to get in there and weld them, but what exactly am i needing to weld? does anyone have any other pics?
-
-
So much fun to play with the tools I have here....
We welded the PSRS Sleeve to the Control Arm
-
**
-
-
**
-
As a welder my self...if you are welding them correctly.. IE NOT spot welding. They will not break... since these have been tested in MI for more than a year welded.. and not broke. I think we're good. But yes they have to be done correctly.
-
Thats all well and good Lynn, but the weld cost me $20 on the existing part. Being as I don't have the time, patience, skills or desire to handle the work involved to swap what I already have that works perfectly fine I offered a solution to others in the same boat. When I have the desire, tools and enough extra cash to trash a prefectly good item then I'll look into a replacement. Right now a $20 weld every few years is a lot more cost effective.
Like I said, if the knowledge that the Alta part had these problems was more prevalent a few years ago when I did the swap I would have gone in a different direction. Since I didn't and many others have not as well I thought I'd share a fix. The intent is not to argue the efficacy of the part but to share a fix to a common ailment we who choose this part are afflicted with. -
**
Page 1 of 3