Aaaand the GTI wins. It was a good fight, but the margin was significant. I have to say I'm a little surprised, too. They are both great cars in their own right: I had two GTIs, and my dad had an early Miata. I think it was Crashton betraying his own car and voting for the GTI which set the tone. Crashton: beware of your Miata taking revenge and actually breaking--something they never do...
Okay, bloodied, but not down, the GTI has another challenging foe ahead: and here it is:
Would you rather...
...or...
![]()
Page 19 of 48
-
Eric@Helix New MemberMotoring Alliance Founding Sponsor
-
GTI.
Fun to drive. Easy to work on. Parts are available and cheap. -
ScottinBend Space CowboySupporting Member
Which BMW is that.......?
-
I love the Miata, but I've always wanted a Mk1 GTI.
-
Eric@Helix New MemberMotoring Alliance Founding Sponsor
-
TheModFather Well-Known Member
- May 15, 2012
- 5,310
- 11 years in the ARMY, 2 years of being a multitale
- Ratings:
- +5,322 / 0 / -0
This one I'm going to have to pic the GTI. Parts are cheaper for a DD or walk.
-
Crashton Club Coordinator
Parts for an NA Miata aren't very expensive. There is a growth industry in parting out wrecks. Lots of Miatas being parted out so there is a plentiful supply of cheap used parts. I'd think that the GTI may be harder to get parts for, they are 6 years older than the oldest Miata & many have been run to death & tossed aside. Having driven a few roadsters in winter I'm staying with the GTI as a 365 daily driver.
Edit missed the fact the GTI won.
I'm still with the GTI, but will do a most thorough pre-flight come spring.
I'd rather drive that big beautiful BMW, but I'd rather own that GTI. -
Having never driven the BMW I can only guess that it would nice BUT I also guess that it would be very expensive to repair. Given the GTI is front wheel drive would make it a better all weather daily driver that is much easier to repair when and if needed so once again I'll choose the VW.
-
ScottinBend Space CowboySupporting Member
The 635 is a nice car, but it is a car that can't decide what it is......Luxo-cruiser or sports car. Still would go with the GTI.
-
Dave.0 Helix & RMW PoweredLifetime Supporter
A GTI ? I don't think so. :lol: -
Code3_Mini New Member
- May 8, 2014
- 299
- Full-time Military, part-time headbanger
- Ratings:
- +299 / 0 / -0
I still have to go with the GTI. That 635csi is much bigger in comparison and I couldn't flog it around the track like I could the GTI.
-
Sleek Motoring Local Shop Owner
GTI! Better complete package!
-
vetsvette MINI Alliance Ambassador
I would have to go with the BMW. Back in the early 90's a buddy let me test drive his M6 version for a few days to try and convince me to take it off his hands. Great car! I regret not getting it to this day, but at the time I was a single parent with two kids in high school and on that rare occasion good sense won out.
-
mrntd Well-Known MemberSupporting Member
- Sep 30, 2011
- 1,762
- Male
- Sales and Marketing manager
- Ratings:
- +1,763 / 0 / -0
-
mrntd Well-Known MemberSupporting Member
- Sep 30, 2011
- 1,762
- Male
- Sales and Marketing manager
- Ratings:
- +1,763 / 0 / -0
For the first one I have to pick GTI as I loved mine. That is until Chuck lets me drive his Miata. Then I may change my mind.
For the second 635 CSi with the buffalo leather interior option. -
Eric@Helix New MemberMotoring Alliance Founding Sponsor
GTI is now 2-0 with a solid victory over the BMW.
As an aside, I've spent half a lifetime driving cool cars, and never once has it succeeded in attracting a woman whose attention I wanted. My experience is that fancy cars are a net negative with women as a whole. In fact, my wife married me despite my irrational car choices. The opposite might not be true. The other day I saw a moderately attractive youngish woman driving an air cooled 911. After stuffing my tongue back into my agape gob, I came to my senses, realizing that this skinny, married, balding and drunk 47-year-old had no chance.
But back to much more important issues. Who's next for our two-time champ the Rabbit GTI?
Would you rather...
...or...
a 60s Bronco?
Page 19 of 48